Amish Oatmeal Best pie – You must make this pie. MUST! This unbelievable pie is everything you dream pie to be. Soft and gooey, full of flavor and made with Red Mills gluten free oatmeal.

Hello from the best oatmeal recipe or Amish Oatmeal Pie. Yes, this post is all about oatmeal.

Originally it suppose to be about oatmeal cookies but this pie won my heart and I need it to share now. I like to think you need to make this pie as soon as possible. It will change your life.

Since our life now is so “never mind, I don’t want to talk about it”, this pie is the best solution for all of us.

Yes, we all need this pie in order to forget “real every day life”.

So, why I love this pie so much? What is so special about it?

Let me start with …

DESCRIPTION OF AMISH PIE

How about…

• REMARKABLE

• STRIKING

• RICH

• SUPER DELICIOUS

• GOOEY

• MOUTH-WATERING

Yes, this pie is homemade heaven. It starts with an unbaked pie shell. You know who has the best recipe for pie shell. 5 star cookies – Make 6 pies from one recipe or if you are on diet and you want only 3 CHECK THIS LINK!

Also, if you don’t like to make homemade pie crust you can use store-bought version. It is up to you but our recipe for pie crust is super easy to make. (and so cheap)

In case you are wondering why somebody would use oatmeal in pies I am going to answer to you. And in order to do that I have to go back, way back into 1800. (Hello 1800… I am so happy to escape 2020). BTW, not really. It was bad year too…but I have to give you an answer. (see below)

During the civil war pecans were so expensive and not easy to find. So what was the solution?…Oatmeal, yes people use oatmeal in order to create tasty desserts. And because of that we have the best Amish Oatmeal Pie which kind of taste like pecan pie. (kind of..)

Also, I have to admin I like Amish Pie way more than Pecan Pie…unless is boozy Pecan Pie.

Now, since you know so much about this 5 star Amish recipe we can move to the kitchen and make it happen. YES, we are ready for our baking show.

Like always our first step is getting ingredients or I like to call it…

SHOPPING LIST

• pie crust (homemade or store-bought)
• brown sugar
• old-fashion rolled oat (I love Red Mill)
• white sugar
• milk (2%)
• butter (unsalted)
• eggs (large, organic)
• vanilla extract
• salt

Equipment Needed

pie dish (9 inch)

mixing bowl

ACTION TIME

Making Amish Oatmeal Best Pie

Ingredients

1 unbaked pie shell

3 large eggs, beaten

1 1/4 cups brown sugar, packed

1/2 cup white sugar

1 cup old fashioned rolled oats

3/4 cup milk

1 tsp pure vanilla extract

3 TBSP butter, unsalted and room temperature

1/2 tsp salt

Optional: heavy cream, ice cream

INSTRUCTIONS

Preheat oven to 350 F.

Be sure you have in the freezer homemade pie crust (or use store-bought)

Using a mixing bowl add: brown sugar, white sugar, oats and salt. Stir using a metal spoon.

Then add milk, beaten eggs, butter and vanilla extract.

Mix until incorporated.

Pour the mixture into prepared pie shell.

Place in oven and bake for about 50 to 55 minutes or until pie is baked.

• 

• 

• 

• 

• 

Cool it.

Serve with your favorite ice cream or whipped cream. Decorate with shaved chocolate.

Enjoy and share the best Amish Oatmeal Pie.

Review the Steps

-Unbaked pie shell

-Mix all dry ingredients: brown sugar, white sugar,oats and salt

-Then add beaten eggs, milk, butter, vanilla extract. Stir until incorporated.

-Pour into unbaked pie shell

-Bake at 350 F for 50 to 55 minutes

-Cool. Enjoy with your favorite ice cream, whip cream and shaved chocolate.

Quick Note

Eggs – Use large eggs

White and Brown Sugar – Please, be sure to use both. (if you forget white sugar the recipe will not work…trust me. I did it)

Oatmeal – I really like organic from Red Mill. You use what you have

Pie Shell – unbaked, frozen. Use store-bough or homemade.

Totally Optional: You can add 1/2 cups chopped walnuts or pecans to the filling.

FINAL NOTE

Amish Oatmeal Best Pie is the best pie recipe.

Comforting and so easy to make. You don’t know what is better…the pie crust or the crispy oats topping that forms once the pie is baked. (just check the pictures…). Add to that your favorite ice cream or whip cream and you have the best dessert. So comfy and full of richness.

Yes, this Amish Pie is what we need NOW!

Final Grade: A+

OTHER PIE LINKS

Grandma’s Cheese Dream Pie-Memory of my Grandma

Euro Apple Pie – The Best Winning Power

The best pie cake you will ever try – The Best Pumpkin Pie Cake

Eat-More Peanut Butter Pie – Canada Soul

Baked Pasta Cheese Pie (Ridiculously Simple)

Happy Birthday to my Friend-Cake Pie Recipe

Before we print the recipe, are you ready to eat?

I know, I am…let’s do it.

To print this recipe please check the box below.

Don’t forget: PRINT – MAKE – SHARE

PRINTING THE RECIPE

Thank you for visiting the best food blog, 5 star cookies.

Love and hugs

from your favorite

Cookie

See you soon…

Enjoy and share.

And be KIND!

So, are you ready to eat this gooey, living in a bubble creation? I know the answer … Enjoy.

• 

INSTAGRAM

TWITTER

PINTEREST